Hello. I quite enjoy your “bold” claim that you provide proof, but I don’t believe you have. Please note my counter argument is not my own belief as I do not believe in a supreme god type figure. But did you prove what you say?

You begin by stating that “god must either exist or not exist” and that if you prove one you disprove the other.

And I suppose you would be correct if your first premise was true.

However, since you define God as have all possible power without any possible limit, you then limit the being you claim that you’re modeling as all powerful, a contradiction to your own terms “God must either exist “or” not exist.


A supreme being must be a transcendent being that could “both exist and not exist”

Just like a transcendent supreme god could both lift a rock too heavy to lift and not lift the rock.

So, you have perhaps proven with logic that a finite semi supreme god of limited capability absolutely does not exist, and no more than that!